Top 10 Mattresses September 2023
Best Mattress Online, where millions have placed their trust in our expert reviews and data-driven recommendations. Our carefully curated mattress list offers a diverse selection, from luxurious memory foam to innovative hybrid options, all tailored to cater to various sleep needs. Explore our top-notch collection and discover your perfect night's rest.
We receive referral fees for products purchased through links on this website. Full Advertising Disclosure Bestmattressonline.org is a mattress review website that compares brands, provides information about their mattresses construction, warranty, return policy and more. We do not list all mattress brands out there. We do our best to provide accurate information, but we can't guarantee that it is. Mattress companies often change their products, prices, warranty periods and more. The best way to get accurate information is to go to each company's official website. We receive referral fees for products purchased through links on this website. Referral fees we receive from mattress companies do impact our rankings, ratings and reviews. See our How We Rate page and Terms of Use for more information. Bestmattressonline.org includes advertising by Puffy LLC.
1
Ranked
Verified Customer ReviewsVerified Customer ReviewShould have bought sooner!
"I bought the hybrid lux. I cannot say enough about it. I have tried a few mattresses on the internet and returned them all. This is the best mattress I've ever owned period. I have back, joint and leg problems. This is supportive yet soft on joints. I also got the adjustable base and use the vibration ever night to help me fall asleep. All I can say is - just try it.!!!!!"
Verified Customer ReviewPuffy for the Win!
"With so many different brands out there, it can be a whirlwind trying to find the perfect mattress. I'll save you some research time by saying that you just gotta go with Puffy! It provides the right amount of support without being too firm, which I love."
Verified Customer ReviewI LOVE MY PUFFY
"It's been a long time since I slept this good. I am finished with the whole store shopping for a mattress. I was hesitant about purchasing online for a mattress and now I'm happy I did. I recommend this mattress over any store-bought mattress because I have tried them all, from high prices to average prices and been disappointed until now. Puffy RULES!"
2
Ranked
Verified Customer ReviewsVerified Customer ReviewAmazing Pressure Relief
"We've had our LuxeBreeze Firm for over a year and love it! It solves my heating issues & back/shoulder pain. I wake up way more energized than I did with my old pillow top."
Verified Customer ReviewVery comfortable mattresses
"I was having back pain and it has definitely made a difference. I wake up rested and no pain. We have an adjustable base with split mattresses. My husband has the firm mattress and I have the soft mattress."
Verified Customer ReviewNow we're sleeping
"All other's mattresses were giving us back issues until one day I said enough. We sleep through the whole night with no issues, except now both hate getting up."
3
Ranked
Verified Customer ReviewsVerified Customer ReviewNot mad, just disappointed
"The mattress came with defects and gaps between the different kinds of foam."
Verified Customer ReviewLove the Legend
"I want to sleep all the time, I love the legend mattress so much!"
Verified Customer ReviewDefinitely A Legend
"I've been sleeping on a Leesa mattress for years. I bought one when I had some back issues and thought it couldn't be beat. Wrong."
4
Ranked
Verified Customer ReviewsVerified Customer ReviewNice bed but just a little firm
"Amerisleep had excellent customer service. They helped out with all my issues. I don't know if my weight is too light but the mattress feels firm for me. I thought it was softer."
Verified Customer ReviewYes, I would buy this product again!
"Great product and lives up to the hype in regard to softness."
Verified Customer Review1 year later
"I was worried my AS5h might be too soft when I ordered it. It's perfect. I'm a big guy and a side sleeper. My arm never falls asleep anymore and my back rests straight."
5
Ranked
Verified Customer ReviewsVerified Customer ReviewAmazing sleep!
"We bought our i8 about seven months ago and our sleep quality has been life-changing. Our favorite position is Zero Gravity and the foot warmer is a great feature!"
Verified Customer ReviewWanted to love this i8 mattress
"For a year I kept a log of various sleep numbers and pillows I used. I tried every Sleep Number and worked with Sleep Number customer service people. They were very nice to work with but I never was able to find a number that didn't give me a backache. I concluded that I need a firm mattress."
Verified Customer Reviewi8 review after 30 days
"The bed is very comfortable and I really like the adjustable settings. It does take some time to figure out the best setting. We have a regular king mattress no split and feels like we both move to the middle over the night. Our previous mattress, we never felt like we were sinking to the middle."
6
Ranked
Verified Customer ReviewsVerified Customer ReviewSofter than expected
"I wanted to love the midnight luxe but unfortunately it was way softer than I had expected, resulting in some lower back pains every morning."
Verified Customer ReviewComfy and quality
"So happy with our new queen-size luxe mattress. Delivery and setup were a breeze. It does take about a month to soften up a bit, so give it a little time if it at first feels too stiff."
Verified Customer ReviewNice bed!
"Great bed!! Easy setup! Super comfortable. I love the platform for it."
7
Ranked
Verified Customer ReviewsVerified Customer ReviewSo comfortable
"My husband and I bought our split king mattress a little over a year ago. We had an issue initially - with one side losing air. Saatva was pretty quick to replace the air pump system."
Verified Customer ReviewNo-Hassle Delivery
"From beginning to end, I loved my experience working with Saatva, almost as much as we both love our new mattress. The website is easy to use. When questions arose, and I contacted customer service, everyone was courteous, efficient, and yet took the time necessary to answer my questions."
Verified Customer ReviewA Great Mattress That's Not For Everyone
"The issue revolves around the foam casings that are placed around the interior of the air bladders. When the bladders are filled with air, at any setting from 20 and up to 50 (the ), the foam casings are lower than the bladders causing the user to sleep or sit on the mattress at an angle—or tilted—about five (5) degrees or more. This causes the lower body (legs and feet) to roll to the left or right depending on which side of the bed one or both are sleeping or sitting on (queen or king size mattresses)."
8
Ranked
Verified Customer ReviewsVerified Customer ReviewNot for sure
"Side sleeper here, for some reason it feels stiff, is it just me or is this normal? Been having this mattress for about two months, hopefully it will get better as time goes by."
Verified Customer ReviewI was expecting a lot
"It's met all my expectations and more. Each night getting in bed, I exclaim how good it feels. It's the few mattress companies that DON'T OFF-GAS. This was my first priority. Then, the second was how it felt."
Verified Customer ReviewI love the Purple
"I love the Purple Hybrid Premier 4! It's comfortable yet very supportive in any position I've tried. It's breathable, so I'm not hot tossing and turning around all the time. It also feels very durable and definitely meant to last. I don't think I could ever use another mattress now!"
9
Ranked
Verified Customer ReviewsVerified Customer ReviewAlready sagging in the middle!!!
"We have been using this mattress for several weeks now but it's already sagging in the middle!"
Verified Customer ReviewHigh quality. Luxury. Great back support.
"It's a wonderful mattress every night for over 2 months so far. This Dream Cloud King Gel Memory Foam Mattress is so great for me and my hubby so we LOVE it!"
Verified Customer ReviewNice hybrid mattress
"This California King Mattress arrived compressed into a very heavy roll packed into a cardboard box. I recommend unrolling it directly on the bed frame for easiest handling."
10
Ranked
Verified Customer ReviewsVerified Customer ReviewAbsolutely no structure and is some shaped
"Final verdict- do I think that this mattress is worth the money? To be honest I am not sure. While there is no doubt it's a very well made mattress and it's super comfortable, but I have issue with the fact that it has not fully expanded in some spots after 7 full days."
Verified Customer ReviewTop quality, but at a price
"This arrived vacuum sealed and rolled inside a thick cardboard box, and is very heavy, I recommend two person lifting. Once unpacked, the mattress should be left to "inflate" or normalize for about 24 hours before sleeping."
Verified Customer ReviewLiterally cloud 9!
"This mattress is AMAZING!!! It's literally like laying on clouds made of gloriousness. It's so soft and comfy. It is very cooling and allows your body to breathe at night all while confirming to your arches and body shape."
Top 10 Mattresses Comparison
1
|
2
|
3
|
4
|
5
|
6
|
7
|
8
|
9
|
10
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Starting Price | $2,249 | $4,099 | $1,999 | $2,099 | $3,399 | $1,373 | $2,595 | $3,045 | $1,849 | $1,499 |
| Sale Price | $899 | $4,099 | $1,599 | $1,649 | $2,799 | $1,099 | $2,245 | $3,045 | $1,099 | $999 |
| Total Savings | $1,350 | $0 | $400 | $450 | $600 | 20% | $350 | $0 | 40% | 33% |
| Free Pillow | ||||||||||
| Free Protector | ||||||||||
| Free Sheets | ||||||||||
| Consumer Reports Recommended |
||||||||||
| Endorsed by American Chiropractic Association |
||||||||||
| Free Nationwide Shipping and Returns |
||||||||||
| Lifetime Warranty | ||||||||||
| Made in USA | ||||||||||
| Sleep Trial | ||||||||||
| Visit Site | Visit Site | Visit Site | Visit Site | Visit Site | Visit Site | Visit Site | Visit Site | Visit Site | Visit Site |
See Editor's #1 Choice
See Now
FAQ
-
What's a good budget?
Buying a new mattress is a significant investment in your sleep health so it’s important to have a good budget for it. The budget for a high-quality mattress will usually range from $1,000 to $1,700. With this budget, you should be able to buy a great mattress that is comfortable, supportive, and will last for a long time. -
What to look for in a cooling mattress?
When searching for the perfect cooling mattress, pay attention to the cover fabric and firmness level. Some mattresses come with specially designed cooling covers that increase breathability and wick away moisture, thereby helping regulate temperature. Look for terminology such as 'Cooling Phase Change Material', 'Cool-to-the-Touch Cover', or 'Temperature Regulating Technology'. Furthermore, although the firmness level doesn't directly influence cooling, it can impact heat retention by affecting how much of your body is in contact with the mattress. Medium-firm mattresses usually offer a balanced combination of support and temperature neutrality, making them an ideal choice for those seeking a cooling mattress. -
What mattress is best for back pain?
Our favorite mattresses for back pain are the Puffy Lux Hybrid and the Leesa Legend Mattress. The Leesa Legend features two layers of springs that relieve pressure and reduce lower back pain. As for our number-one choice, the Puffy Lux Hybrid, the mattress’s specialized foam layers and coils base target key pressure points and provide unique support for back pain. Additionally, the Puffy Lux Hybrid was ranked the #1 mattress for side sleepers with back pain by Forbes. -
What is a hybrid mattress?
A hybrid mattress combines an innerspring system with memory foam or latex layers, providing both body-contouring comfort and robust support. Its design enhances breathability compared to traditional memory foam mattresses due to the airflow-promoting innerspring layer. Essentially, hybrid mattresses aim to balance the benefits of their various components, offering a versatile sleep solution. -
Is a memory foam or hybrid mattress better?
While memory foam mattresses offer classic all-foam comfort, hybrid mattresses take the benefits of a memory foam mattress to the next level. Hybrid mattresses contain multiple memory foam layers with a spring base. This provides added support so sleepers won’t sink in and the mattress won’t sag. As a result, hybrid mattresses have a longer lifespan than memory foam mattresses, thanks to the extra-sturdy layer of springs. Additionally, hybrid mattresses disperse body heat away from the mattress, allowing for extra air circulation so you won't sweat or overheat while sleeping. -
Are these mattresses made in USA?
Most of the mattresses on our list are made in the USA, except for DreamCloud and Nectar. Both DreamCloud and Nectar mattresses are made and assembled in China. Mattresses that are made domestically in the USA spend less time being transported or sitting in a warehouse so you’ll get the mattress in its best condition. Additionally, American-made mattresses are usually constructed using higher quality materials and processes. -
How important is a mattress warranty?
When a product is expensive, having a generous warranty will give you peace of mind when making your purchase. The warranty protects the product against defects in craftsmanship or any physical flaws, so you can either exchange the product or get the issue fixed during the warranty period. Buying a mattress with a lifetime warranty is the safest option because the mattress will be protected for as long as you’re sleeping on it. Additionally, a lot of brands offer lengthy trial periods so you can test your mattress before committing to it.