Top 5 Mattresses in a Box™ | 2019

header image

Based on Customer Reviews | Updated:

  • Forbs-logo
  • lifehack-logo
  • business-logo
  • tnw-logo
  • salesforce-logo
  • inc-logo
We have helped over 1,000,000 consumers find the perfect mattress online.

How Mattresses Are Ranked?

Rankings are based after researching thousands of verified customer reviews. We never accept free products from any company.

RANKED #1

Google Site Rating 4.9

  • Made in the USA, customers say it's like sleeping on a cloud. Featured on Consumer Reports, Puffy LUX is ranked the most comfortable mattress by multiple review sites. In addition to comfort, sleepers experience less back pain and feel relief with Puffy's Adaptive Cloud Technology. Puffy comes with a Lifetime Warranty & 101 Night Free Trial with a Money Back Guarantee.
  • Excellent value for the money for a top quality mattress, Puffy's Cloud Foam provides pressure relief, sleeps cool, and conforms to the body. Puffy is the only mattress that comes with a Stain Resistant Cover.
  • The top layer is a Cooling Cloud Pressure Relief Foam. This is known to give you that sleeping on a cloud feeling. The middle Plush Cloud layer actively adjust to your body for maximum comfort. It includes a Climate Adaptive middle layer which prevents temperature fluctuations. Its bottom layer is a Firm Core Support Foam. All layers are CertiPUR-US Certified.

Get $300 off Puffy Lux

RANKED #2

Rating - 8.9 /10

  • The Purple Mattress is made of hyper-elastic polymer which is unlike other mattresses that are mostly made of memory foam. The top layer feel is different and it springs back very quickly.
  • Purple Mattress comes with a limited warranty. Its top layer does have a bounce to it which is unique in and of itself.
  • The top layer consists of their known Hyper-Elastic Polymer™ Smart-Comfort Gel Grid. In addition the bottom layers consist of Polyurethane Foam.

RANKED #3

Rating - 8.7 /10

  • Amerisleep comes with a Cellian Cover that allows for cool sleeping. Overall a good mattress for most types of sleepers due to its bio-based foam.
  • Amerisleep sleeps well but is on the pricier side. In addition, most reviewers have complained about it being a bit on the soft side as well.
  • Top layer consists of Bio-Pur™ Memory Foam. The middle layer is Affinity Transition Polyurethane Foam. Bottom layer is Bio-Core™ Polyurethane Foam.

RANKED #4

Rating - 8.6 /10

  • Leesa is one of the better mattresses out on the market providing a soft bed for a good night sleep. The cooling layer works decently providing a good feel overnight.
  • The Leesa does have a bit of a smell to it compared to other memory foam mattresses. However, overall it is a good choice for a mattress due to its supportive feel.
  • The top layer consists of Avena® Perforated Foam. The bottom layers are Polyurethane Memory Foam.

Get $150 off Leesa

RANKED #5

Rating - 8.4 /10

  • Top cover is quite stretchy and plush. The white fabric gives a it a nice soft look to the mattress. The cover is zippable allowing you to easily remove it for washing.
  • It does include latex so that is something to watch out for. In addition, there is a very slight sinking you would experience more than usual with memory foam mattresses.
  • The top layer is latex foam and the bottom layer is Polyurethane Support Foam.

What to Look for When Buying a Mattress

Support and Comfort

There are two major factors to look for when you are searching for a new (great) mattress: support and comfort. When you lie down on a mattress, it should properly support your body, adapting your shape in the correct areas to ensure your spine remains aligned while you sleep through the night. Proper alignment from head to toe is essential for healthy sleep and to alleviate back pain. While being supportive of your body, a proper mattress should provide pressure relief. Pressure points on your body, typically shoulders, hips, or back, are what cause you to toss and turn at night. The reason memory foam mattresses have become so popular as of late is due to the fact that they are excellent at being both supportive and comfortable.

Stiffness/Softness



This falls into the same category of support and comfort. A mattress should be neither too hard nor too soft. It should be as neutral as possible, to keep your body and spine in a balanced position. If a mattress is too stiff, it will compress too many pressure points on your body, pinching nerves and stopping blood flow. If you often wake up with the feeling of pins and needles on your body, it's likely from the mattress being too stiff. And when the opposite occurs, with a bed that is too soft, you will get a concaving "hammock" effect, which will cause back pain from improper alignment of your spine. It is important to find a mattress with a neutral feel, that will be both firm and soft in the correct places.

Temperature Neutrality

One of the most often neglected features of a mattress (and the downfall of many lower end foam mattresses) is the breathability or temperature neutrality of the material. Although the conforming feel that memory foam mattresses provide is one of their greatest features, the lower end models are often susceptible to the oven effect, where the mattress retains body heat and starts to get uncomfortably warm through the night. On rare occasions, a mattress might be the opposite: not retaining enough temperature, and consistently leaving you feeling colder than you would like (I'm looking at you, water beds). The newest generation of foam and standard inner-spring mattress companies tend to incorporate special materials into their products to allow the bed to breathe and disperse heat more evenly. But, as we can see from the reviews, some companies perform better than others in this aspect.

Durability

It goes without saying that most mattresses aren't cheap, especially if you are looking for a good one. It's a large investment to make, so when you purchase one, it is important to find a mattress that will last you for years. It's important to find a mattress that has been designed with durability in mind. Some mattresses may start off feeling amazing, but they start to sag or develop a body imprint after just a few months of use. This tends to result in improper spine alignment and increased pressure points on your body, which would be devastating to your sleep cycle. If you're going to be investing in a new mattress, make sure the manufacturer has designed a durable base and proper materials to ensure it will keep its shape over the years. Look for a mattress that offers a minimum 10 year warranty.

We review products we love and by clicking on the products below, we may receive a commission at no cost to you.